Theoretical Frameworks and Aesthetic Interrogations
Art that is a living organism subverts the fundamental categories of aesthetics inherited from the Enlightenment. The Enlightenment drew a hard line of separation between moral and legal duties on the one hand and aesthetic appreciation on the other. This line is drawn by Immanuel Kant in his construction of a `disinterested' aesthetic judgement. Aesthetic appreciation of a living organism is in direct conflict with Kant's principles for a disinterested aesthetic judgement. Works of bio-art subvert both formalist and conceptual approaches to art. These artworks require an empirical, rather than metaphysical, engagement with the 'living' systems that require 'care' and, in turn, offer challenges for interpretive responsibilities for the bio-artists to the organisms that they have created. Artworks that grow, reproduce, and die defy the artwork-as-commodity principle that is pervasive in the art world. In this regard, bio-art is an example of what contemporary philosopher Jane Bennett refers to as 'vibrant matter', the non-human materials that have agency, whether of man or not, and resist the anthropocentric approaches that regard non-human resources as passive. In this case, phenomenological approaches that emphasize the embodied experience of the bio-art are appropriate, as bio-art invites a whole cocktail of visceral experiences from the audience that include fascination, revulsion, wonder, and anxiety. The bio-art world of contemporary art raises questions of elitism and accessibility because of the technical infrastructure and specialist scientific knowledge that they require to create bio-arts, and the public bio-art audience is not specialists in the biological sciences. This raises the debate of whether bio-art primarily 'speaks' to the scientific community or to the public and the question of whether intermediary discourse articulates the critical potential of the artwork, the spectacle, and the provocation in the absence of any meaningful technical discourse.

